Anyone have a Henley yet? Run large/small?

Any update on this? I read on another thread that the sweatshirts are sewing up rather long, and the fit guide for henleys is the same as that for sweatshirts. That said, I like a large in the T-shirts but do not want 33-inch sleeves, as the fit guide suggests would be the case for a large henley--35- or even 36-inch sleeves would be better. Should I size up to an XL?

I've got to think they're a lot like the long sleeves, and the fit seems to be spot on. Slightly slim perhaps; the L's for the long sleeves are definitely not baggy (I usually settle on Mediums for the button downs these days after dropping from Slim L's).

I received my size small black heavyweight henley and was able to wash, dry and wear it. It seems to run big and is baggier and boxier than my Gustin size small tees.

I am really hoping it shrinks with subsequent washes. It fits most like this fit pic from the Gustin site:

Yes, a size small. Wish I had measured it before iI washed it... I have an olive henley in production I can measure at some point but you know how sizing can vary with batches.

I think I like my shirts snug more than I am skinny!

I was expecting it to be more snug based on the product description which says a henley should have a close fit etc.

It feels a little blousy as well. I wore it under a leather jacket and it was sticking out the bottom of the jacket and bunching up like a skirt.

I imagine this fit will be great for everyone looking for a relaxed fit. I was just expecting the fit to be more in line with the tees I guess.

aw dangit. Shoulda stuck with medium then. I'm going to be swimming in mine.

I think you should reconsider your swimwear. 

I like the henley. It isn't mind blowing, and the buttons are a bit small, but it fits me well. I wouldn't call it boxy, but I have a broad frame so it works.

Also, the cuffs are nicely done. They retain their shape well, which is important to me in a long sleeve.

Medium for both. I do classic medium in the button downs too fwiw. I could probably pull off a slim medium but I want a little extra room in them. I tried a classic small once, and it fit except for the comical length.

I find if you want a good fit from a stretchy fabric, go a size down from your heavyweight size.  My heavyweight tee and henley are both spot on at large, but my pigment dye tee is spot on at medium.  I'm going to go medium on the waffle henley because I expect it to stretch.